I completely agree. The mugging to the camera is cute and all, but what I like the gag reel for is to see them flubbing their lines! That's what's fun! I mean, they had to totally destroy that whole "Sam Winchester wears makeup" dialog at least a few times- I was really hoping stuff like that would be in the gag reel.
I was really looking for that sceen too MG. How many times did Jared say that they messed up? Nine? And that even their camera crew couldn't keep even a straight face? I thought that would definitely be on their, I'm sorry it wasn't.
I agree with you guys. I kept waiting for that to be on gag reel. Also JA said in one scene he gets tangled up trying to get out of the impala. He even said "I'm sure it will make the gag reel". Don't get me wrong I do love it but it had a feeling of being thrown together at the last minute.